Judge's ruling may remove roadblock to oil refinery

BISMARCK, N.D. — A North Dakota judge has finalized his recent conclusion that state regulators don't have a say in the site of an $800 million oil refinery being developed near Theodore Roosevelt National Park, potentially clearing a major roadblock for the project.

An attorney for one of the environmental groups challenging the project says the judge's recommendation could set a bad precedent by effectively allowing developers to police themselves.

Administrative Law Judge Patrick Ward in a nonbinding recommendation last month said the Davis Refinery being developed by Meridian Energy Group won't have a large enough capacity to fall under the jurisdiction of the Public Service Commission.

The Environmental Law and Policy Center and Dakota Resource Council disputed that, noting that the project's permit from the Health Department allows construction of a facility big enough to warrant PSC review under state law.

Ward in a decision dated Wednesday said that doesn't matter.

"The fact that the (Health Department) issued a permit for Meridian to build a refinery up to 55,000 (barrels per day) does not mean they need to construct one of that size," Ward said. "The proposed 49,500 bpd facility sworn to in the affidavit from the chief executive officer of Meridian is beneath PSC jurisdiction."

Under state law, oil refineries with a capacity of 50,000 or more barrels require a site permit, a process that involves public hearings and can take half a year or longer to complete. Meridian initially told the media, investors and government officials that the refinery would have a capacity of 55,000 barrels, but the company later lowered the figure to 49,500. It has denied trying to skirt state law.

The two environmental groups that filed a complaint with the PSC maintain the Health Department permit indicates the project might end up being larger than the company maintains. They want permission to obtain more information from Meridian so they can explore the veracity of the company's stated plans for a 49,500-barrel refinery.

Ward in his decision recommended that not be allowed, and he again urged the PSC to dismiss the groups' complaint. The commission could act as early as its next regular meeting, scheduled for Wednesday. During an informal discussion of the matter last month, one commissioner indicated she likely would vote to heed the judge's advice, while the other two PSC members held off on indicating their position.

Dakota Resource Council attorney JJ England said that if the PSC follows the recommendation, it "may have the effect of restricting the jurisdiction of executive agencies in North Dakota."

"The judge's recommendation all but asks the PSC to waive its power to review the safety and location of this major oil refinery so long as the company swears that it does not need a permit," he said Thursday in a statement to The Associated Press. "In other words, it allows companies to police themselves."

Meridian began site work this summer for the refinery 3 miles (5 kilometers) from the park. Opponents fear pollution will mar the park's scenery and erode the air quality at the state's top tourist attraction. Meridian disputes that, and supporters believe the plant will boost the area's economy.

The company hopes to begin operating the refinery in 2020, though the project faces a legal challenge of its state air quality permit. Meridian also still needs state water and wastewater permits, and it will need to prove once the refinery is built that it meets air quality standards.


Follow Blake Nicholson on Twitter at: http://twitter.com/NicholsonBlake

Related News

Slain runner from NYC laid to rest in Massachusetts

Aug 16, 2016

A New York City woman killed while out running near her mother's Massachusetts home was remembered at her funeral Tuesday for the light she brought to the lives of everyone she touched

'American Horror Story' coming to Halloween Horror Nights

Aug 17, 2016

The ghosts, vampires and other freaky misfits from "American Horror Story" are coming to Universal Studios

Casino mogul Wynn readies lavish new Macau resort

Aug 17, 2016

Steve Wynn's Macau resort brims with auspicious Chinese symbolism, and the U.S. casino mogul will need luck on his side as launches his $4.2 billion Wynn Palace project in the gambling hub as growth downshifts

You may also like these

'American Horror Story' coming to Halloween Horror Nights

Aug 17, 2016

The ghosts, vampires and other freaky misfits from "American Horror Story" are coming to Universal Studios

Hawaii authorities urge awareness of raw food risk

Aug 17, 2016

Hawaii authorities are urging diners to be aware of the risks of eating raw and undercooked food after they traced a hepatitis A outbreak to frozen scallops served raw at a sushi restaurant chain

Rare Tyrannosaurus rex skull arrives at Seattle museum

Aug 19, 2016

Paleontologists with Seattle's Burke Museum have unearthed the bones of a Tyrannosaurus rex that lived more than 66 million years ago, including a rare nearly complete 4-foot long skull

Traveller SEA (South-East Asia) is for wanderlust looking for an adventure in the South-East Asia region and the rest of the world.

Contact us: sales@tvlseacom.com